1) Acted idly 2) Dallied amorously 3) Fiddled 4) Fiddled around 5) Like half the theme answers 6) Played 7) Played around 8) Played to the grand finale 9) Played with 10) Trifled 11) Trifled with 12) Trifled with a game fellow 13) Used a magic wand 14) Was flirtatious Found on https://www.crosswordclues.com/clue/toyed